Bye Bye (Live @ Oprah)
I thought i prefer this live verison than the one she sang on American Idol Season 7...
The background singer did not dominate her (unlike on American Idol...)
And the background singer did not try to do Mariah Carey's trademark whistle vocals (which one of them did during her performance on American Idol and went OUT OF TUNE!!!)
Mariah, you ROCK!!!
the makings... in the studio recording...